Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Transcriber B's avatar

csofand— good to see this. Sad though it is.

What do you suppose the blip in 2017-18 was all about?

* * *

Re: "requirement that all religious exemption requests be granted without inquiry into the sincerity of the request.”

I find it outrageous that some bureaucrat can inquire into the sincerity of my or anyone else's stated beliefs. Our Bill of Rights does not grant religious freedoms only to members of an established church or temple, nor is there any authority granted to any one anywhere to determine what is or is not valid in the privacy of our own minds and hearts and souls.

This is our constitutional right, and it has been systematically violated. Unfortunately many people do not understand this. I know people who did not apply for a religious exemption because they thought they had to have a letter from their priest or their pastor or their rabbi, or what have you. But that is not the case. A sincerely stated religious belief is enough. If I say it is sincere, and I sign my name to it, then for all legal purposes it is. And where the religious exemption applications were not respected— I sincerely hope that those who violated others' rights in this respect will be held to account before the law, and harshly.

On this infelicitous subject, for anyone who might be interested in further reading, I would recommend Thomas Harrington's essay, "Clerical Abuse Redefined"

https://brownstone.org/articles/clerical-abuse-redefined/

Expand full comment
David Shohl's avatar

The exceptional rise in FY2018, which as you say we've seen in some other states, is bizarre -- I wonder what caused it. I appreciate your sifting through all this information and presenting it to us & future researchers.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts