I think you’re right to “simply take the members removed number and calculate what percentage that was of the total members.”
The fact that the resulting percentages confirm your earlier work -- the largest increases for Alaska and Georgia, for example, happen in 2021 -- seems to vindicate the method’s validity.
Thank you David. Your vote of confidence is very welcome. I know you wouldn't say so if you did not agree with its merit. It's funny what contortions you will put yourself through unnecessarily. The simplest approach just seemed too ... simple.
Thank you for keeping on trying to show solid numbers for what so many of us are seeing and feeling - giant holes in the fabric of our towns and communities. Something is weird........
last summer when we went to our annual city summer festival, I told my husband it seemed as though there were far fewer people than years before. Where were the jostling crowds and running kids? Had all the older crowd really passed away or become too disabled to attend?
He said, "Well, you can't see dead people".
I thank you for still digging for the truth in numbers though not being a statistician - whether by your last method of the ratio of members added to members removed or back to your first idea of tallying members removed and calculating what percentage that was of the total members.
You must live in a much smaller city than my Portland. It is harder here to pick up on any missing people. But I think it must be happening. Your observation is probably correct, sadly.
I hope my analysis of the numbers isn't getting too finicky and makes sense. I'm trying to make this evidence as solid as I can.
Thank you for that. Thank your husband for pointing that out too. It is an important concept that is not intuitive. I've had to think about this a long time just to make the few baby steps towards understanding that I have. It is kind of mind-numbing stuff!
That was exactly my thought at a family member's birthday party I attended recently. Everyone looked well enough and there was dancing. Many remained seated throughout, however, and I know that one guest had an active clot that necessitated his using a walker, another was being treated for a brain tumor, one had been suffering months of severe GI issues.. and a couple more examples along those lines.
The celebrant's sibling had died 2 months earlier of a truly ghastly turbo cancer, and there were several friends who certainly would have been there had they been alive— they too, all up-to-date with their covid boosters, had died in 2022-2024. The two closest friends of the birthday gal canceled at the last minute due to illness— said illnesses looking a lot of like adverse reactions to the jab if you ask me.
Transcriber B your report of the family get together is very unsettling. You and our friend from Alaska have put actual people on the numbers. I too have started to hear about more people here with similar ailments. I hope some day to be able to retire my projects for lack of of anything to report.
csofand, it just so happens that last night I finished a transcript of a 2023 testimony that listed friends and family injured by the jabs— none willing to connect the dots. It was a long list, and much like the one I could have provided myself. And I don't think my personal list would be unusual. I'll be posting that transcript very soon.
Transcriber B, I always look forward to anything that you are working on. That is a simple and powerful thing ... a list of people in your life and what has happened to them. Do you know if anyone has done a larger project in that vein?
Hi csofand— thanks for your kind words. In answer to your question, in some comments sections (alas I no longer recall which) I recall seeing a couple of people mention keeping a tally of people they know who died or suffered adverse events following their jabs. Other than that the main such "personal circles" research I am aware of in this vein is Steve Kirsch's surveys on his Substack. If you haven't already seen them, I would recommend taking a look. https://kirschsubstack.com/archive
You may have to dig around in there some to find all of them. But I can say that Kirsch is a whiz at data interpretation and he was able to draw some solid conclusions based on those surveys. I think they're quite important.
* * *
Going a bit broader—
I imagine you're also already aware of Mark Crispin Miller's reporting on the died suddenlys.
Early on Tessa Lena did a haunting interview with a woman who was collecting obituaries.
"In this episode of the "Make Language Great Again" podcast, I talk to Kathleen Brown, a retired dental hygienist in Nova Scotia, Canada. Kathleen is looking into obituaries of people under 65 who died suddenly or unexpectedly in Nova Scotia, Canada."
"The COVID-19 Humanity Betrayal Memory Project (CHBMP) was founded to document and preserve the stories of those who were harmed by COVID policies, protocols, and mandates. Its origins trace back to the early archival effort hosted on prions.rip—an independent, victim-focused platform that began collecting firsthand stories from individuals and families as the scope of the betrayal was becoming clear."
Oh, Transcriber B, what a terrible tally in one family!
It may sound odd to say, but I think it's wonderful there was a party - and dancing! - at all.
I haven't been to a large party in quite awhile....
But the dystopian, nightmarish thing is that no one is SAYING anything. Or if they do, I suppose most would all say, "Age" or "these things happen" (as if cancer is normal - except that it is all too normal now.) Cancer was fairly prevalent in middle age and older people when I was growing up but was extremely rare in young people.
And of course I suppose people who trust allopathic "medicine", probably are still blaming covid.
I'm so sorry dear Transcriber. It is turning out as I feared back in 2021, but more steadily and slowly than I could have imagined, like a drip, drip, drip of disease and death.
I know quite a few who have come back from their life threatening strokes, clots and paralysis but who are now completely wedded to their constant medical testing, devices and medications.
Yes, Джил, as you say, "It is turning out as I feared back in 2021, but more steadily and slowly than I could have imagined, like a drip, drip, drip of disease and death."
Thank you for doing this work, csofand! You’re are helping confirm what we all see and know. And if you continue to monitor you will be able to alert people to any changes you see.
I think you’re right to “simply take the members removed number and calculate what percentage that was of the total members.”
The fact that the resulting percentages confirm your earlier work -- the largest increases for Alaska and Georgia, for example, happen in 2021 -- seems to vindicate the method’s validity.
Thank you David. Your vote of confidence is very welcome. I know you wouldn't say so if you did not agree with its merit. It's funny what contortions you will put yourself through unnecessarily. The simplest approach just seemed too ... simple.
Thank you for keeping on trying to show solid numbers for what so many of us are seeing and feeling - giant holes in the fabric of our towns and communities. Something is weird........
last summer when we went to our annual city summer festival, I told my husband it seemed as though there were far fewer people than years before. Where were the jostling crowds and running kids? Had all the older crowd really passed away or become too disabled to attend?
He said, "Well, you can't see dead people".
I thank you for still digging for the truth in numbers though not being a statistician - whether by your last method of the ratio of members added to members removed or back to your first idea of tallying members removed and calculating what percentage that was of the total members.
Thank you.
You must live in a much smaller city than my Portland. It is harder here to pick up on any missing people. But I think it must be happening. Your observation is probably correct, sadly.
I hope my analysis of the numbers isn't getting too finicky and makes sense. I'm trying to make this evidence as solid as I can.
A proportional change in a small amount can be significant.
If a small number like 1% increases by 1% of the total, that's 100% increase.
(That's what my husband says. But I'll admit at this point I'm lost.)
Thank you for that. Thank your husband for pointing that out too. It is an important concept that is not intuitive. I've had to think about this a long time just to make the few baby steps towards understanding that I have. It is kind of mind-numbing stuff!
Джил — re: "Well, you can't see dead people".
That was exactly my thought at a family member's birthday party I attended recently. Everyone looked well enough and there was dancing. Many remained seated throughout, however, and I know that one guest had an active clot that necessitated his using a walker, another was being treated for a brain tumor, one had been suffering months of severe GI issues.. and a couple more examples along those lines.
The celebrant's sibling had died 2 months earlier of a truly ghastly turbo cancer, and there were several friends who certainly would have been there had they been alive— they too, all up-to-date with their covid boosters, had died in 2022-2024. The two closest friends of the birthday gal canceled at the last minute due to illness— said illnesses looking a lot of like adverse reactions to the jab if you ask me.
Transcriber B your report of the family get together is very unsettling. You and our friend from Alaska have put actual people on the numbers. I too have started to hear about more people here with similar ailments. I hope some day to be able to retire my projects for lack of of anything to report.
csofand, it just so happens that last night I finished a transcript of a 2023 testimony that listed friends and family injured by the jabs— none willing to connect the dots. It was a long list, and much like the one I could have provided myself. And I don't think my personal list would be unusual. I'll be posting that transcript very soon.
Transcriber B, I always look forward to anything that you are working on. That is a simple and powerful thing ... a list of people in your life and what has happened to them. Do you know if anyone has done a larger project in that vein?
Thank you.
Hi csofand— thanks for your kind words. In answer to your question, in some comments sections (alas I no longer recall which) I recall seeing a couple of people mention keeping a tally of people they know who died or suffered adverse events following their jabs. Other than that the main such "personal circles" research I am aware of in this vein is Steve Kirsch's surveys on his Substack. If you haven't already seen them, I would recommend taking a look. https://kirschsubstack.com/archive
You may have to dig around in there some to find all of them. But I can say that Kirsch is a whiz at data interpretation and he was able to draw some solid conclusions based on those surveys. I think they're quite important.
* * *
Going a bit broader—
I imagine you're also already aware of Mark Crispin Miller's reporting on the died suddenlys.
https://markcrispinmiller.substack.com/
* * *
In addition there are some focussing on mining the obituaries. Patrick E. Walsh in Ireland https://patrickewalsh.substack.com/
* * *
Early on Tessa Lena did a haunting interview with a woman who was collecting obituaries.
"In this episode of the "Make Language Great Again" podcast, I talk to Kathleen Brown, a retired dental hygienist in Nova Scotia, Canada. Kathleen is looking into obituaries of people under 65 who died suddenly or unexpectedly in Nova Scotia, Canada."
by Tessa Lena, March 23, 2022
https://rumble.com/vy9agt-honoring-those-who-died-suddenly-a-conversation-with-kathleen-brown-in-cana.html
Transcript of selected brief excerpts: https://transcriberb.dreamwidth.org/74084.html
* * *
There is also the magnificent documentation in the CHD People's Studies
https://live.childrenshealthdefense.org/chd-tv/the-peoples-study/
* * *
And also Michael Gray Griffith's Cafe Locked Out interviews in Australia.
https://cafelockeddown.substack.com/
(many, many interviews)
* * *
React19.org testimonies
* * *
National Citizens Inquiry in Canada
https://nationalcitizensinquiry.ca/
* * *
And the Humanity Betrayal Project cases
https://chbmp.org/cases/
"The COVID-19 Humanity Betrayal Memory Project (CHBMP) was founded to document and preserve the stories of those who were harmed by COVID policies, protocols, and mandates. Its origins trace back to the early archival effort hosted on prions.rip—an independent, victim-focused platform that began collecting firsthand stories from individuals and families as the scope of the betrayal was becoming clear."
Thank you for this compendium, I wasn't aware of a few of them.
I remember Michael Gray Griffith's Cafe Locked Out interviews in Australia being earth shattering.
Oh, Transcriber B, what a terrible tally in one family!
It may sound odd to say, but I think it's wonderful there was a party - and dancing! - at all.
I haven't been to a large party in quite awhile....
But the dystopian, nightmarish thing is that no one is SAYING anything. Or if they do, I suppose most would all say, "Age" or "these things happen" (as if cancer is normal - except that it is all too normal now.) Cancer was fairly prevalent in middle age and older people when I was growing up but was extremely rare in young people.
And of course I suppose people who trust allopathic "medicine", probably are still blaming covid.
I'm so sorry dear Transcriber. It is turning out as I feared back in 2021, but more steadily and slowly than I could have imagined, like a drip, drip, drip of disease and death.
I know quite a few who have come back from their life threatening strokes, clots and paralysis but who are now completely wedded to their constant medical testing, devices and medications.
I wonder for how long.
Yes, Джил, as you say, "It is turning out as I feared back in 2021, but more steadily and slowly than I could have imagined, like a drip, drip, drip of disease and death."
Thank you for doing this work, csofand! You’re are helping confirm what we all see and know. And if you continue to monitor you will be able to alert people to any changes you see.
Thank you Tom. I will keep going. It is my small way of staying sane and hopefully contributing to an eventual accounting.
I appreciate your support.